USING HIGH-FEED MACHINING STRATEGIES TO GET TO NET SHAPE2014-02-10 - By Chris Mummaw
This article originally appeared in Moldmaking Technology. Click here to view or download the article in PDF format.
The most important issue facing the mold and die industry in recent years is throughput. Throughput is the amount of work a shop can complete in a set amount of time. This idea of productivity has been under constant review with the pressure from overseas competition.
To survive in the global market with shrinking leadtimes, manufacturers are forced to embrace new time-saving technology. Recently, that technology has been high-feed tooling. Grinding technology has transformed high-feed tooling from large insertable tools to a range of sizes and styles. This new tooling selection has proven to be an irreplaceable solution in many applications and effective for all industries involving machining.
In this article, high-feed tooling will be defined and proven with some common examples. By using a high-feed machining strategy, this technology can be used on any machine tool. Keeping throughput in mind, high-feed tooling and a highfeed machining strategy can be the key to maximizing shops’ machining efforts.
With new five- and six-axis CNC grinding technology, cutting tool manufacturers have been able to create almost any geometry. With this increase in grinding technology, high-feed tooling has been reborn. The definition of high-feed geometry is producing a positive cutting edge out of a series of continuous radii with no tangent point to induce wear. The geometry must allow the chip to flow up and out of the cut quickly and smoothly. This cutting motion allows the use of heavy chip loads to achieve very high feedrates.
The geometry also must induce a chip thinning factor. The chip thinning factor allows the cutting tool to generate all cutting forces upward toward the spindle. With these cutting forces in place, it helps eliminate vibration and tool deflection, which results in a more rigid cutting condition that is safer for your spindle. To achieve these requirements for high-feed tooling, it is important the tool be fully ground in a 3-D helical motion. Straight grinding will not produce true highfeed results.
In the past, high-feed tooling was only available as an insertable tool in larger diameters. As stated above, grinding technology has reinvented high-feed tooling. High-feed tooling is now available in a two-flute insert in sizes 3/8" (10 mm) to 1" (20 mm) or as four flute solid carbide in sizes 1/8" (3mm) to ½" (12 mm). With this overlap of technology, many smaller roughing applications can be streamlined. Machining times in some applications have been reduced by up to 70 percent. This reduction in machine time is due to the high-feed geometry. By allowing heavy chip loads on small diameter tools, high feedrates can be achieved in smaller machining applications. High-feed tooling is proving to be an irreplaceable solution in most roughing applications.
High-Feed Machining Strategy
High-feed geometry is the future of high-speed roughing. In the past, roughing operations have been evaluated only on their metal removal rate. This evaluation usually puts into process the machining strategy of using the biggest tool possible and working down sizes. However, by properly using high-feed tooling, users can achieve the same—if not better—metal removal rate with a much smaller tool.
A high-feed machining strategy should be based on eliminating re-roughing operations and getting to allowable corner radii or net shape faster. To illustrate the different strategies when roughing, a multiple cavity job example has been chosen. The same core geometry was roughed using a conventional roughing approach on one cavity and a high-feed roughing approach on the other.
Material Size: 12.5" x 13" x 3.375"
Target Corner Radii:0.270"
Machine tool: Makino V-77
Programming Software: Cimatron
This used a traditional roughing process when starting from a solid block of steel. This approach will usually begin by using a large insertable tool and executing re-roughing operations to achieve the target corner radii. This example will use average cutting parameters per the tool and material.
Example 1, Rouging operation 1
Tool Diameter: 1" insertable
Corner Radii: 6mm (12mm round insert)
Number of Flutes: 2 flutes
Width-of-Cut: .600" (60 percent of the tool diameter)
Spindle Speed: 4500 rpm
Feedrate: 120 ipm
Total Machining Time: 5:23:21
It is common in cavity and core work to have a target corner radius or net shape to proceed with semi-finish or finishing operations. To achieve this net shape, a series of re-roughing operations are needed with smaller diameter tools. The target corner radii for this example is 0.270; therefore, this example will need a re-roughing operation with a ½" diameter tool.
Example 1, Rouging operation 2
Tool Diameter: 1/2" back draft insertable
Corner Radii: .060"
Number of Flutes: 2 flutes
Width-of-Cut: .500" (50 percent of the tool diameter)
Spindle Speed: 4000 rpm
Feedrate: 85 ipm
Total Machining Time: 1:40:38
The results of Example 1 show that to achieve the desired net shape, it has taken two operations. Combining both machining run times has resulted in an approximate run time of 7 hours and 4 minutes. This is the time it has taken to get the net shape needed to proceed with finishing operations.
As mentioned in Example 1, to get to the most important and longest running operations—semi-finishing and finishing—programmers and machinists have to achieve a target corner radius or net shape. In traditional machining approaches, this would begin with the biggest tool possible and then work down sizes. However, with high-feed geometry, smaller diameter tools are able to achieve higher metal removal rates than conventional larger diameter tools. Therefore, programmers and machinists can focus more on net shape when approaching cavity and core work.
In Example 2, keeping in mind the 0.270 target corner radius, a highfeed approach would be starting the roughing operating with a ½" high-feed tool. This approach will eliminate the need for further re-roughing operations and produce the target net shape.
Example 2, Roughing operation 1
Tool Diameter: 1/2" high-feed tool
Corner Radii: .052" programmable radii
Number of Flutes: 4 flutes
Width-of-Cut: .600" (60 percent of the tool diameter)
Spindle Speed: 5000 rpm
Feedrate: 350 ipm
Total Machining Time: 2:01:39
By using high-feed tooling and a different machining approach, the part is at the desired net shape to proceed with finishing operations in approximately two hours. This has reduced machining time by almost 70 percent when compared to Example 1.
In addition to the reduction in machining time, this high-feed approach used fewer tools, less programs and less setup time to achieve the same net shape. This high-feed approach to roughing has more than doubled the machine’s capacity and increased the shop’s throughput.
An additional benefit of using highfeed tooling is the ability to direct the cutting forces toward the spindle. As explained earlier, this direction of force results in minimal tool deflection. This can allow programmers or machinist to rough to closer tolerances. Instead of leaving extra stock for an additional semi-finishing operation, some cavities and cores can be roughed close enough to begin finishing operations. By using high-feed tooling, shops can increase machine capacity by decreasing processes and run times.
With advancement in high-feed tooling sizes, styles and geometries, programmers and machinists can put the speed back in high-speed machining. By embracing this new time-saving technology and machining strategies, manufacturers can remain competitive in today’s global marketplace. Highfeed tooling can be the answer to many roughing applications in every industry that involves machining. This quickly achieved net shape geometry can give the programmer or machinist the flexibility to remove re-roughing or even semi-finishing operations.
A high-feed approach can reduce the amount of processes needed to complete the job and boost process efficiency. High-feed tooling and the machining strategy associated could be the key factor in maximizing your shop’s roughing efficiency. This new tooling selection has provided a new solution to all sizes of workpieces. With highfeed tooling and a high-feed machining strategy, programmers and machinists can begin maximizing their machining efforts by decreasing cycle times and increasing throughput.
Note: The author would like to acknowledge BICO Steel Service Centers for donating the P20 material for the test.